Expected move vs actual move: how did MSFT and GOOGL compare after earnings?

Oct 30 options priced about ±6.7% for Microsoft and ±7.5% for Alphabet. On Oct 29 Microsoft moved -0.16%, inside; Alphabet moved -12.6%, outside.

As of the 2026-10-23 session, Oct 30 options priced a one-standard-deviation move of about ±6.7% for Microsoft and ±7.5% for Alphabet. From the close before each report (Oct 28) to the first close after it (Oct 29), Microsoft moved -0.16%, inside that range, and Alphabet moved -12.6%, about 1.7 times its expected move and outside it. Amazon reported after the Oct 29 close, so its first post-report close is too recent for this post, which uses data through Oct 29, and it is not scored.

An expected move is a market-implied size of move, read from option prices at one moment, and it does not forecast direction or the outcome. One quarter of two stocks proves nothing about how accurate expected moves are. The expected moves below come from our pre-report post, published 2026-10-28 with figures as of the 2026-10-23 session.1

What an expected move is

The expected move turns implied volatility into a range around the stock price. The formula from the pre-report post is the stock close times the at-the-money implied volatility times the square root of days to expiry over 365. The result is one standard deviation. In a normal distribution the price would end inside that range about two times in three; real returns have fatter tails, so moves beyond it happen more often than that.

Scoring it after the report means asking one plain question: did the stock's move stay inside the range the options priced, or not?

When the three companies reported

  • Microsoft announced its fiscal year 2027 first-quarter results on October 28, 2026, after the close of the market, with its call webcast at 2:30 p.m. Pacific Time.2
  • Alphabet released its third quarter 2026 results after the Oct 28 close (its Form 8-K was accepted by the SEC at 4:01 pm ET).3
  • Amazon released its third quarter results after the Oct 29 close (its Form 8-K was accepted by the SEC at 4:05 pm ET).4

All three reports came after the 4:00 pm ET close, so the "before" price is that day's close and the "after" price is the next session's close. This post does not discuss the results themselves, only the stock moves.

The worked example: expected vs actual

Expected moves are for the Oct 30 weekly expiry, priced as of the Oct 23 session (7 days). Actual closes are from Nasdaq.com historical quotes.5

StockReport (date, time)Expiry usedExpected move ($ / %)Actual move, close to close ($ / %)Inside or outside
MSFTOct 28, after the closeOct 30, priced Oct 23±$35.22 / ±6.7%Oct 28 $531.01 to Oct 29 $530.14: -$0.87 / -0.16%Inside
GOOGLOct 28, after the closeOct 30, priced Oct 23±$24.09 / ±7.5%Oct 28 $324.89 to Oct 29 $283.82: -$41.07 / -12.6%Outside
AMZNOct 29, after the closeOct 30, priced Oct 23±$23.66 / ±9.5%Not scored: first close after the report is Oct 30, after this post's data cutoffNot scored

Microsoft

The change is the first close after the report minus the close before it, in dollars:

change=after−before=530.14−531.01=−0.87\text{change} = \text{after} - \text{before} = 530.14 - 531.01 = -0.87

As a percent of the close before the report:

percent=changebefore=−0.87531.01=−0.16%\text{percent} = \frac{\text{change}}{\text{before}} = \frac{-0.87}{531.01} = -0.16\%

Against the dollar expected move of 35.22:

ratio=size of changeexpected move=0.8735.22=0.02\text{ratio} = \frac{\text{size of change}}{\text{expected move}} = \frac{0.87}{35.22} = 0.02

The move was about 0.02 times the expected move. A 0.16% move is well inside ±6.7%.

Alphabet

change=after−before=283.82−324.89=−41.07\text{change} = \text{after} - \text{before} = 283.82 - 324.89 = -41.07
percent=changebefore=−41.07324.89=−12.6%\text{percent} = \frac{\text{change}}{\text{before}} = \frac{-41.07}{324.89} = -12.6\%
ratio=size of changeexpected move=41.0724.09=1.7\text{ratio} = \frac{\text{size of change}}{\text{expected move}} = \frac{41.07}{24.09} = 1.7

In percent terms the result is close to the same figure:

percent ratio=12.67.5=1.68\text{percent ratio} = \frac{12.6}{7.5} = 1.68

A 12.6% move is outside ±7.5%, at about 1.7 times the expected move.

A cross-check against the Oct 23 range

The pre-report post also published each stock's range by Oct 30, built from the Oct 23 close: $489.37 to $559.82 for Microsoft and $296.58 to $344.76 for Alphabet. Placing the Oct 29 close against those ranges, in dollars:

MSFT above the low=530.14−489.37=40.77\text{MSFT above the low} = 530.14 - 489.37 = 40.77
MSFT below the high=559.82−530.14=29.68\text{MSFT below the high} = 559.82 - 530.14 = 29.68
GOOGL below the low=296.58−283.82=12.76\text{GOOGL below the low} = 296.58 - 283.82 = 12.76

Microsoft's Oct 29 close sat inside its range, $40.77 above the low and $29.68 below the high. Alphabet's Oct 29 close sat $12.76 below the low of its range, outside it. Both views give the same verdict.

Three caveats, stated plainly

The time windows differ. The expected move was priced on Oct 23 for the whole 7 days to Oct 30, while the report-day move covers one session, the Oct 28 close to the Oct 29 close. The Oct 30 close is not used because it is too recent for this post. Applying the Oct 23 percent to the Oct 28 close is an approximation. The verdicts are not close calls (0.16% against 6.7%, 12.6% against 7.5%), and the range check gives the same answer.

An expected move is a size, not a forecast. It is a one-standard-deviation, market-implied size of move. It does not say which way a stock will go, and it does not say what a company will report.

Two outcomes are far too few. Under a normal model about 68% of outcomes, roughly two in three, land inside one standard deviation, and about 32%, roughly one in three, land outside. Real stock returns have fatter tails, so moves outside happen more often than that. One inside and one outside is therefore no evidence that the expected move was right or wrong. Scoring accuracy needs many reports scored the same way, not one quarter of two stocks.

How options traders read this

The expected move is a yardstick for size. Comparing a report-day move with it tells you whether the move was small or large relative to what the options were charging for, and that is all. A related pattern is what happens to option prices after a report: implied volatility often falls sharply once the announcement resolves the uncertainty, a common pattern rather than a rule, which our post on IV crush after earnings walks through.6

Each stock has a public page with the current numbers: the Microsoft expected move, the Alphabet expected move and the Amazon expected move. Each is a once-a-day end-of-session snapshot, delayed at least two days, and now shows a later session than Oct 23, so its numbers will differ from this post's.

How to practice this

Pick a stock with a report coming up, write down its expected move from the first expiry after the report date, and then score it the same way: close before, first close after, the change, the percent and the ratio. Keep a running tally over many reports, since one or two tell you little. In CaymanBot you can open MSFT in the app and follow options across a report in the $100K paper account, with no real money at stake. In the first two Learning Mode stages, each trade on the feed comes with a plain-English sentence you can check against the strike, expiry and premium. A free account shows options data delayed 16 minutes (60 minutes without an account).

Educational only, not investment advice.

Notes

  1. CaymanBot, "What move did MSFT, GOOGL, AMZN and AAPL options price in before earnings?" (published 2026-10-28): expected moves from CaymanBot's public expected-move pages, end-of-session snapshot of the 2026-10-23 session, OPRA options data delayed at least 48 hours, read 2026-10-28. https://caymanbot.com/blog/big-tech-earnings-expected-move-msft-googl-amzn-aapl ↩︎

  2. Microsoft, "Microsoft Announces First Quarter Results" (HTTP 200, read 2026-10-31 07:08 ET). https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/investor/earnings/fy-2027-q1/press-release-webcast ; timing from "Microsoft announces quarterly earnings release date", Oct. 7, 2026 (HTTP 200, read 2026-10-31 07:08 ET). https://news.microsoft.com/source/2026/10/07/microsoft-announces-quarterly-earnings-release-date-69/ ↩︎

  3. Alphabet, "Alphabet Announces Third Quarter 2026 Results", Exhibit 99.1 to Form 8-K, SEC acceptance 2026-10-28 4:01 pm ET (HTTP 200, read 2026-10-31 07:09 ET). https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1652044/000165204426000080/googexhibit991q32026.htm ↩︎

  4. Amazon.com, "Amazon.com Announces Third Quarter Results", Exhibit 99.1 to Form 8-K, SEC acceptance 2026-10-29 4:05 pm ET (HTTP 200, read 2026-10-31 07:09 ET). https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1018724/000101872426000038/amzn-20260930xex991.htm ↩︎

  5. Nasdaq.com historical quotes, "Close/Last", MSFT and GOOGL, sessions 2026-10-28 and 2026-10-29 (HTTP 200, read 2026-10-31 07:10 ET). https://www.nasdaq.com/market-activity/stocks/msft/historical and https://www.nasdaq.com/market-activity/stocks/googl/historical ↩︎

  6. Options Industry Council, "The Crush Is Real". https://www.optionseducation.org/news/the-crush-is-real ↩︎

  7. Options data from OPRA, delayed at least 60 minutes.

Frequently asked questions

How did Microsoft's actual move compare with its expected move?

Microsoft closed at $531.01 on 2026-10-28, before its report, and at $530.14 on 2026-10-29, a move of -0.16%. As of the 2026-10-23 session, Oct 30 options priced about ±6.7%, so the move landed inside the range.

How did Alphabet's actual move compare with its expected move?

Alphabet closed at $324.89 on 2026-10-28 and at $283.82 on 2026-10-29, a move of -12.6%. That is about 1.7 times the ±7.5% that Oct 30 options priced as of the 2026-10-23 session, so it landed outside the range.

Why is Amazon not scored?

Amazon reported after the 2026-10-29 close, so its first close after the report is 2026-10-30. That session is newer than this post's data cutoff of sessions through 2026-10-29, so no Amazon close is used.

How often should a stock land outside its expected move?

Under a normal model about one time in three, because an expected move is one standard deviation. Real stock returns have fatter tails, so moves outside the range happen more often than that in practice.

Does one quarter show whether expected moves are accurate?

No. One quarter of two stocks gives two outcomes, far too few to confirm or refute anything. Judging accuracy needs many reports scored the same way.

Put the research in one place

Start free. Free account: options data delayed 16 minutes. No account: 60 minutes. Premium adds alerts and Strategy Lab, and real-time options data for users who complete the OPRA non-professional attestation.

Start free