How do you paper trade options? A step-by-step practice run on a real SPY quote
Paper trading is placing simulated options orders against real quotes with fake money. Here is one practice run on a real SPY call quote, step by step.
You paper trade options by placing simulated orders against real market quotes with simulated money: you pick a contract, decide what price you would pay, size the position against a practice account, and log the trade, but no order reaches an exchange and no real money is at risk. It teaches the mechanics well: order entry, reading the bid and the ask, sizing, journaling. It cannot teach how real fills feel under pressure or how a real loss feels. This post walks through one practice buy of a real SPY call quote in a $100,000 paper trading account, with every cost worked out step by step.
What paper trading is
Paper trading means you act out a trade without sending it to the market. The quotes are real, the account balance is simulated, and the result is a record of what would have happened at the prices you assumed. In practice it usually means a simulated account inside an app.
The quote you practice against has two sides. The Options Industry Council (OIC) describes the bid as the price a buyer is willing to pay for the option and the ask (also called the offer) as the price where a seller is willing to sell; the chain shows the top of each side.1 The quotes in a typical option chain are the national bid and offer (the NBBO), which the Options Price Reporting Authority (OPRA) builds by collating prices from all options exchanges.1 The gap between the two is the bid-ask spread, and it is the first cost a practice trade should account for.
What paper trading teaches well
- Order entry. Choosing the contract, the quantity and the price, and checking the order before it goes in.
- Reading the quote. Seeing where the bid and the ask sit, and what the spread costs on the way in and on the way out.
- Sizing. Deciding how much of the account one position uses before entering it.
- Journaling. Writing down why you entered and what would make you exit, then comparing that plan with what happened.
What it cannot teach
Paper results do not prove a strategy works with real money. Simulated fills may be easier than real ones, and practice does not reproduce the pressure of watching real money fall. Treat a paper record as practice in the mechanics, and nothing more.
The worked example: one SPY call, as of the 2026-10-16 close
The quote below is Cboe's delayed end-of-day quote for the 2026-10-16 session, for the SPY Nov 20, 2026 $770 call, contract code SPY261120C00770000.2 SPY closed that session at 763.25. Another of our posts shows this same contract at an earlier print during that session; the figures here are Cboe's end-of-day quote, so they differ slightly. This is a practice walk-through only: nothing here says where SPY or the call goes next.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| SPY close, 2026-10-16 | 763.25 |
| Contract | SPY Nov 20, 2026 $770 call |
| Bid / ask | 10.99 / 11.08 |
| Last trade price | 10.98 |
| Volume, 2026-10-16 | 4,266 contracts |
| Paper account | $100,000 |
| Cost of 1 contract at the ask | $1,108 |
| Cost of 1 contract at the mid | $1,103.50 |
| Share of the paper account (ask fill) | 1.108% |
| Buy at ask, sell at once at bid | -$9 |
| Most the long call can lose | $1,108 |
If you need a refresher on where these columns sit in a chain, our guide to reading an options chain covers the bid, the ask, volume and open interest.
Step 1: where the strike sits
The $770 strike sat above the 763.25 close, so the call was out of the money: SPY would have to rise above 770 by the 2026-11-20 expiration for the call to have any value at expiry. That sentence describes how a call works; it is not a view on whether SPY gets there.
Step 2: the fill price you assume
A paper account lets you pretend you got any price. The habit worth building is to write down the price you assumed and why. Two common choices are the ask, which is what a buyer pays to trade at once, and the mid, halfway between the bid and the ask:
One contract covers 100 shares, so the premium paid in dollars is:
The ask fill costs $4.50 more per contract than the mid. A mid fill is not promised in a real market; the gap between the price you hoped for and the price you got is called slippage. Assuming the ask in practice keeps the record honest.
Step 3: the position as a share of the account
Size the trade before you enter it, not after. Assuming the ask fill, the position uses:
Our position size calculator runs the same check for any account size. A useful rule for practice: if a position would be too big for your real account, it is too big for the paper one too.
The most a bought call can lose is the premium paid, $1,108 here, if it expires worthless.
Step 4: the round trip
Now check what the spread costs if you buy and then sell right back. Buying is at the ask and selling is at the bid, so with no price change at all:
That is -$9 per contract before SPY moves a cent. If the terms for entering and exiting are new, our post on buy to open and sell to close explains them. A paper account that fills both sides at the mid would hide this cost, so log it yourself.
How to read the practice run
Four habits come out of this one trade:
- Write down the fill price you assumed and why (ask, mid, or a limit in between).
- Size the position as a share of the account before entering, not after.
- Log the reason for the trade and the exit plan in a journal, then compare with what happened.
- Treat the paper account like real money: if a position would be too big for your real account, it is too big for practice.
None of these numbers say whether buying this call was a good idea. They show what it costs to enter, what share of the account it uses, and what the spread takes on a round trip. Those are the mechanics paper trading is for.
How to practice this
Pick a contract you follow, read its bid and ask, and work out the mid, the cost at the ask, the share of your account and the round-trip spread by hand before entering anything. Then place the same trade in CaymanBot's $100K paper account, with no real money at stake, and keep a journal next to it. To look up the contract chain yourself, open SPY in the app. In the first two Learning Mode stages, each trade on the feed comes with a plain-English sentence you can check against the strike, expiry and premium. Our learning hub collects the other basics. A free account shows options data delayed 16 minutes (60 minutes without an account).
Educational only, not investment advice.
Notes
-
Options Industry Council, "Understanding the bid and ask prices for options", on the definitions of the bid and the ask and how OPRA collates quotes from all options exchanges. https://www.optionseducation.org/news/understanding-the-bid-and-ask-prices-for-options ↩︎ ↩︎
-
Cboe delayed quotes, SPY option chain, SPY261120C00770000 and the SPY close, Cboe's end-of-day quote for the 2026-10-16 session (Cboe timestamp 2026-10-17 00:16:22). https://www.cboe.com/delayed_quotes/spy/quote_table ↩︎
Options data from OPRA, delayed at least 60 minutes.
Frequently asked questions
What is paper trading options?
Paper trading is placing simulated options orders against real market quotes with simulated money. No order reaches an exchange and no real money is at risk.
What can paper trading teach?
Order entry, reading the bid and the ask, sizing a position as a share of the account, and keeping a trade journal. In the SPY example, one call at the ask cost $1,108, or 1.108% of a $100,000 paper account.
What can paper trading not teach?
Real fills under pressure and the feeling of real losses. Simulated fills may be easier than real ones, so paper results do not prove a strategy works with real money.
Should a paper trade fill at the ask or at the mid?
Write down which one you assume. For the SPY $770 call quoted 10.99 bid and 11.08 ask, the ask fill cost $4.50 more per contract than the 11.035 mid.
What does the bid-ask spread cost on a round trip?
Buying at the ask and selling at once at the bid loses the spread. For the SPY call that is (10.99 - 11.08) x 100 = -$9 per contract before any price change.